How much longer will the math fairies prevail in the face of such contra-evidence?
...new molecules - including hydrogen, carbon monoxide and water - can form in the winds themselves.I now remind IMP-9, RNP and all those who may have missed/forgotten that I have been pointing out for them (for years now) what the above 'mainstream' group are only just realizing, ie: that PRECISELY THIS kind of 'recycling process' (of older/evolved/complex material/molecules/dust etc, creates 'pristine' Hydrogen etc ALL THE TIME; which newly reformed 'pristine looking' material eventually aggregates into 'new' clusters/galaxies having the 'appearance of being primordial', but are actually newly created from RECYCLED material that MIMICS the 'pristine-looking' material that has too often been INCORRECTLY interpreted/assumed to be 'primordial' which has existed since some ALLEGEDLY BB BEGINNINGS 'era'.
...As you can now see, I have been 'connecting the dots' on this (and many other things) long before 'mainstream has gotten round to doing the same. :)
Various 'peer criticism' responses to BICEP2 and other CMB 'papers' clearly supports my long-stated view that 'space' is a 'mixmaster' of 'localized/extended recycling' processes which, across the eons and across vast space regions, is perfectly capable of producing BOTH the locally observed CMB AND 'elemental abundance forms/ratios'.
Variously scaled galaxy/blackhole POLAR JET processes/ejections of 'deconstructed matter' from accretion discs over eons locally and into intergalaxy/intercluster space is COMMONPLACE. Hence the 'mix' of 'old' & 'pristine' gas/features observed.
Eternal recyling at all scales makes 'one BBang' unnecessary. Remember Occam's Razor! Cheers. :)
...Again, you can see that I have been consistent and ahead-of-the-curve when pointing out the naive/simplistic assumptions/categorizations and mis-interpretations of observations which obviously are recycled/reformed matter aggregating into NEWER, but MISLEADINGLY 'pristine-looking', stars/clusters/galaxies and deep space gases/molecules/dust (as the above PO 'mainstream' work is now, belatedly, confirming me correct about). :)
See the 'pristine/recycled energy-space' hydrogen atom 'gas/plasma' content predicted by SS but only now being 'unexpectedly found' in deepest space by BBers?
Why posit 'Dark Energy' to BBang 'fix'; when Ocam's Razor-SS-predicted, ubiquitously distributed low levels of 'recycling energy-space-matter' will do? :)
...Yet again, you can see what I have long been pointing out for antialias, RNP, IMP-9; and all those who have been depending/waiting on SLOW/INCORRECT 'mainstream' to do their THINKING, and 'connecting-the-OBVIOUS-dots', for them, instead of doing it for themselves, as I have been urging all along.
It is likely much 'deconstructed matter' (reduced to electrons, protons) mass ejected via polar jets eventually 'reconstitutes' to 'pristine' (not alleged 'big bang primordial') atomic/molecular hydrogen in each quasar/galaxy 'hemispheres' region, and also in deep intergalactic space, where it may form 'older looking stars'. Cheers.
THIS kind of 'recycling process' (of older/evolved/complex material/molecules/dust etc, creates 'pristine' Hydrogen etc ALL THE TIME.....
From the above article:...new molecules - including hydrogen, carbon monoxide and water - can form in the winds themselves.I now remind IMP-9, RNP and all those who may have missed/forgotten that I have been pointing out for them (for years now) what the above 'mainstream' group are only just realizing, ie: that PRECISELY THIS kind of 'recycling process' (of older/evolved/complex material/molecules/dust etc,
In my following posts, I will remind of you all of my most recent observations proving my longstanding comprehension of all this.Shouldn't you wait until you comprehend it before you bring up the longstanding business?
Then consider the high energies and quark gluon plasma and fusions and deconstructions going on in the disc-jets systems alluded to. Then see that any 'calculations' are meaningless unless you understand that quark gluon plasma is being created all the time and recycled into deep space to reproduce all the 'observed' abundances/ratios depending on which region or epoch you are observing.See the fuller picture? material of all sorts/sizes recycled into 'new' Quark-Gluon Plasma; which forms 'new' protons, electrons etc; which in turn go on to form 'new' Hydrgen/Helium nuclei etc. Ok? :)
Read in fuller context please. See the 'inverted commas' enclosing 'pristine'? They are to indicate that it's (previous) mainstream orthodoxy cosmologists 'paradigm' that had long been naively/simplistically and untenably, MIS-identifying and assuming incorrectly, that Hydrogen/Helium in the deep (interstellar, intercluster, intergalactic, inter-galactic-cluster) space 'must be' 'primordial' (ie supposedly 'pristine' and un-recycled from alleged BB! Please read and catch up with all the relevant context, mate. Thanks.THIS kind of 'recycling process' (of older/evolved/complex material/molecules/dust etc, creates 'pristine' Hydrogen etc ALL THE TIMEThe DEFINITION of "pristine" is that the material has NOT been recycled through stars and therefore does NOT contain metals IN ANY FORM.
All the other "I've been right all along" claims are equally as silly,..Meanwhile in REALITY, mainstream article/work NOW (eg, as above) increasingly supporting me. :)
See the 'inverted commas' enclosing 'pristine'? They are to indicate that it's (previous) mainstream orthodoxy cosmologists 'paradigm' that had long been naively/simplistically and untenably, MIS-identifying and assuming incorrectly, that Hydrogen/Helium in the deep (interstellar, intercluster, intergalactic, inter-galactic-cluster) space 'must be' 'primordial'
See the fuller picture? material of all sorts/sizes recycled into 'new' Quark-Gluon Plasma; which forms 'new' protons, electrons etc; which in turn go on to form 'new' Hydrgen/Helium nuclei etc. Ok? :)
It's more complex, Ira. To get an overall idea of the full range of recycling, intermediates and outcomes involved, you need to have read all my posts relevant to this constant recyclingI been reading all your irreverent posts for years Cher. They have not improved since you first started with this foolishment.
See the fuller picture?The fuller picture just shows your mental conditions are resistant to whatever it is the doctors are trying on you.
Anyhow, I trust that those who have been attacking ME (instead of doing what I urged them to do/see for themselves) while I have been correct all along,Do you and Trump-Skippy go to the same doctors? It's not helping him either.
Tf and cd8, what you advocate is not the scientific method. And your peers judge you guilty of crankery and bombastic nonsense.
We KNOW that the interstellar and intergalactic media are not pristine, because they have been OBSERVED not to be.Only RECENTLY observed/understood NOW by mainstream; while I have been pointing all this out for YEARS to YOU; while you derided me for being ahead-of-the-curve/mainstream on this (and other) crucial understandings that FALSIFY early naive/simplistic 'BB-pristine' gas/elemental abundance ratios/calculations/interpretations.
The intercluster medium is more complicated, but large quantities of gas that contains no metals have been OBSERVED in such locations. So we KNOW it is out there.NOW you/mainstream do; BUT I've been pointing out these OBVIOUS things for YEARS (while you/mainstream kept 'swallowing the 'Cool-Aid' of BB-based FALSE BELIEFS.
Preposterous! Indeed, even more outrageous than your usual nonsense.You didn't know that innumerable Black Hole Disc-Jet PROCESSES/OUTFLOWS are many orders of magnitude MORE energetic than our LHC; and have been outputting Q-G-Plasma for EONS? Amazing!
Where, for f**ks sake, are you suggesting that Quark-Gluon plasma is generating significant amounts of " 'new' Hydrgen " [sic]?
Why do you do this? You just conjure silly stuff out of thin air in an attempt to make yourself sound knowledgeable, but instead make yourself look stupid.
Was that your New Year Resolution, Ira?Work to have as good a year this year as I did last year. And be grateful if this year is only half as good as last year was.
If so, then you are now well on track to keeping that NY resolution, Ira!Yeah, everything is looking good for me so far. But then I don't like to complain even when I got something to complain about, it can always be worser.
@RNP.We KNOW that the interstellar and intergalactic media are not pristine, because they have been OBSERVED not to be.
Only RECENTLY observed/understood NOW by mainstream; while I have been pointing all this out for
YEARS to YOU;
When will you learn that there are people reading your posts that know much more about astrophysics than you, and that the nonsense you post only serves to show you to be a charlatan troll?LOL
I was addressing ONLY the humongous quantities of hydrogen etc gas content found ONLY SINCE NEW INFRA-RED range telescopes came on line...
MY point ONLY had to do with the fact that ANY deep-space Hydrogen/Helium was deemed BY BigBangBelievers to be PRISTINE (ie, PRIMORDIAL; ie, from Big Bang Beginning); and hence they ALSO ASSUMED that any low-metallicity star/star-cluster/galaxy must also be made from such 'leftover gas from BB!
BUT above NEW article/work NOW agrees NEWLY REFORMED Hydrogen/Helium is CONSTANTLY produced! :)
Give me one example of such humungous discoveries.You are being patently disingenuous, insincere, RNP. I expect any interlocutor attacking me to at least be up to date with ALL the relevant recent discoveries/reviews. READ UP; instead of playing these troll/ego games. :)
I have refuted this point above and even provided a reference as proof.You "refuted" nothing; you conflated/confused two separate issues; and still patently haven't read up, 'connected the dots' appearing in the larger discovery/review picture. Stop being 'myopic', 'pedantic', BIASED. It's that sort of 'blinkers' that left us with 'Big Bang' mess only now being cleaned up.
You fail to understand the article.It's part of bigger picture 'dots' set. Again, stop being myopic and pedantic; see the fuller picture/insights! Eg: consider what is happening in BH disc-jets/winds: Our LHC is PUNY by comparison, yet IT TOO produces Quark-Gluon Plasma that reforms into NEW Protons/atoms! THINK. :)
You REFUSE to give references for your nonsensical claims, OBFUSCATE around subjects where you realise you are wrong, and INVENT physics.......the claim that significant amounts of "new" Hydrogen and Helium can be produced in BH jets really is the silliest thing.........if an interaction produce a "new" particle it must also produce a "new" anti-particle. Were this an anti-proton..*sigh*...incredibly powerful blinkers, RNP!
Mackita is trying to get on it as well.....
mackita (Zeph) is an auto-ignore for me.
Is any further comment needed after that latest demonstration of everything that's wrong and insidiously dangerous with 'the gang' mentality certain 'members' STILL exhibit so insensibly and all too often in this new year as in the last/previous, @Forum? Sad.Mackita is trying to get on it as well.....
mackita (Zeph) is an auto-ignore for me.
it's actually quite fascinating to see how they twist their beliefs and delusions to make themselves feel better
knowledge is power - so studying the benign idiocy of delusional pseudoscience idiots like them is how we learn to deal with the malicious criminally insane fanatic
gang-attacks on the person instead of sticking to the science/logic arguments made!1- you don't post science: you post your opinion on science
you're talking about a pseudoscience idiot who hasn't figured out that its posts are searchable in every f*cking search engine on the interwebzWhile RNP is being addressed by egotistical, malignant, foul-mouthed, bot-voting, science ignoramus @Stumpy even too insensible to see the irony in his driveling 'personal trolling noise'!
nor has it figured out that cursory examination of its inane pseudoscience delusions..Which are being confirmed correct all along with every new mainstream study/review/discovery!
said idiot is so absolutely bereft of intelligence..This from an admitted INTERNET STALKER, LIAR/LIBELER, BOT-VOTING ignoramus BETRAYING all SCIENCE/HUMANITY objectivity/fairness principles ON A SCIENCE SITE! Poor CS.
there is no gang. just a LOT of people who think you're an idiot trollYou mean that SAME "LOT of people" who:
Where have you been, mate!? Please do what I urged long ago: Read up BEFORE you launch into more ignorance-based insults, denials.I was addressing ONLY the humongous quantities of hydrogen etc gas content found ONLY SINCE NEW INFRA-RED range telescopes came on line...Give me one example of such humungous discoveries. Don't worry, I'll do the maths for you if you can't do it.
Tuxford
Jan 30, 2018Yes, but where does all that new matter come from in the first place, given the presence of the massive outflows in the energetic winds destroying the quiescent conditions needed for star formation?? Obviously, the conventional notions of the merger maniacs are still blowing in the winds, while fancying the existence of the illogical black hole with infinite density.
How much longer will the math fairies prevail in the face of such contra-evidence? Our matter is largely born in the centers of galaxies, and distributed therefrom, growing galaxies from the inside out, rather than the reverse.